Edward Elric Myers-Brigs type - MBTI, enneagram and personality type info
That was addressed to scotty :)Nope, you are trying to change the status quo by 2 visible senses of the word, so you're gonna have to do waaaaaay better than such weak arguments lol. I want to back up the site too. honestly I don't mean to take sides, but as a factual interlude: each type develops and utilizes 4 functions, for the ENTJ: Te-Ni-Se-Fi, and for the ENTP: Ne-Ti-Fe-Si. Thinking – Feeling, represents how a person processes information. Thinking means that a person makes a decision mainly through logic.. Most of Brotherhood in particular is just willing his hand clap powers with his mind. ENTJ is one of the least understood types especially for children. Are you a troll or just retarded. for an ENTP he have plenty of Fi moment. He's rare ENTP protagonist. Is he trying to avoid his personal missions. Oh well I'm done here. These symbols like Fe and Fi just represent a certain thing and where has it even been shown that Fe-doms use more Ti than Te for example. NTJs like Ed aren't. Stop projecting. Lol the "sportiest" N-type person is ENTJ :)There's something for you to trash, I don't even care lolll. A winner is generally revealed when the other party needlessly uses foul language or* gets angry. as for scotty, think a little more before you post because (and this bit goes for both of you) impulsive responses aren't helping. There's the whole shadow-function theory as well but that's technically not MBTI. We got one guy saying extrovert, one guy saying "clearly an introvert". However, given his biting sarcasm and the fact that his value system is so fundamental to his being I would have to put him as an INTJ. I can see ENTJ subtype Fi, too. My shortest response yet: but I agree with ILIntp, done. You know intjs better than me, I definitely do believe you :)Indeed, that sounds like something not even an INTJ would say IRL. In this site you can find out which of the 16 types this character 'Edward Elric' belongs to!. NTJs like Ed aren't. He's driven by personal feelings and acts rude as hell to others. Tertiary Fe is well-developed. Duh, your the one who is always arguing "fit. They just weren't necessary. (Fi too strong to be ENTJ, but I digress. LOL apparently you don't understand what those faces even mean. And if you're going to say that he uses too much Se to be ENTJ and then use that as argument for ENTP or INTJ then that's just nuts. (Please don't question my request, it's one of my core Fi values for decent endings)I guess I feign getting worked up to push the discussion in a certain direction. He is less creative with his powers than Gon, yet Gon is nearly unanimously considered ESFP. Oh heck with it, every N-type to an extent other than ENTJ. Yeah and he doesn't want to talk about love or show any vulnerability. I'm just responding to whatever crap you keep putting forward and treating it as such. (just FYI: I've typed myself for a few years now, but that's not it) If you can't even type yourself after all this time. I will always be puzzled how he gets typed as ENTP, when he doesn't use Ne. Jung theorized that the dominant function acts alone in its preferred world: exterior for extraverts and interior for introverts.. and "more than half the time". Simply put - unlike Ed Elric who fits the ENTJ model, I don't fit neatly into one of the 16 models. Appeal to popular opinion is not an argument. Because I don't see how his unwillingness to kill is enough of a reason to be F (at least it's what I see people say). Discover Array, and more, famous people, fictional characters and celebrities here!. An ENTP going on an adventure is probably going to have a bit more fun along the way at the very least, even if they are a directed ENTP. Let me recap: so you had said "NTPs are pretty goofy. hi guys as someone who's been peacefully spectating, I think it would probably be more productive to abandon the goofy point for now because A. He also has really hard times taking a joke which seems more like an inferior Fi thing. It's an understandable request given my type, then we can start :)@i, what are you even talking about. Forget what I just said thought. net/fs71/i/2013/098/b/7/edward_elric_what_i_d_rather_do_then_clean_by_duosmexymaxwell-d60wknv. I think a Six in his position might think like that. Isabel Briggs Myers, a researcher and practitioner of Jung’s theory, proposed to see the judging-perceiving relationship as a fourth dichotomy influencing personality type.. As for ENTP, I know less about MBTI but he fits the quick thinking/brainstorming combination of NeTi, doesn't him. I will agree that INTJ makes more sense than ENTP, but he is way more bold and outspoken than a typical INTJ. I think Ed is an Genius ESFP like TarantinoENFP. He is clearly Fi user, he didn't used the stone even knowing that the souls present in it just suffers and implore to be dead, because his personal values. Don't make absolute statements like that unless you can 100% back it up lol. You may be able to make a by-the-letters argument for ENTP in Ed, but I don't really see the Ne. What if you kill one and there's no turning back and suddenly you're killing all of your threats, what if his superiors just decide to make him their killing weapon. An INTJ with weak I preference being very outspoken and confrontational is not something unheard of (I would know), especially when he feels a possiblity to act on his environment. He`s like an explorer of ideas.
. Is he introverted or extroverted. If I had won after not asking anything else you would have just denied losing. As for the moral side of Fi, he doesn't care about what anyone else wants him to do or to be, is adamant about his principles (I did human transmutation, this is my sin and I'll carry it because what I did is unforgivable. Look, I care about sportsmanship. You've also been more provocative than I have. And I do agree that he can get quite Fi at times but that can also be a plot device just like how Se can be. Good, we can start. So are you proposing he's an Se-aux or dom. I'm watching it, and yeah, he'd be an INTP if he wasn't like 100% extroverted. jpgIt's not about loving work per se but it's about being tightly wound, never taking time to breathe, rather than their relaxed perceiving counterparts. lol "shutting down", more like making idiotic argumentsNot intp: On a purely E/I basis, and the debate in this page has often been on E/I: Entps lie right in the middle of that E/I spectrum, intps do not. He's definitely a Rational (NT) this leaves it as a toss up between INTJ and INTP. And the Ne function can look introverted, which may be why I viewed him that way. " -- Who talks like this in reality. If you enjoyed this entry, find out about the personality types of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood characters list.. That doesn't say anything about the personality of the characters. But I think that's an ineffective to type people based off of these assumptions of a crude model. and to think I didn't think it could get any worse. I understand what people say about the order of the functions and for some people its true and some it isn't. I've always seen him as an INTJ, although I'd gladly admit to being biased here. I strongly agree with ENTJ. The scene is not about work, totally different. Let me work this out, types with strong SE: ESFP, ESTP, ISTP, ISFP, not that I am arguing for them in any sense whatsoever really. Ed is goofy, might be too-goofy-to-be-ENTP-and-everyone-else goofy http://fc01. And you're just plain impossible. This is isn't "I am God and everything I say must be right". And ENTJ are more prone to outbursts than ENTP and INTJ. He can seem to have high Se, but it could very well be written off as just a plot device. "I am ready whenever scotty promises not to get so confrontational when he lose again. Well see, if you're going to convince me he's not ENTJ you're going to have to present a more plausible typing. You said watch 15 seconds so I did, now you talk about the whole episode. (I can't be without this website lol and I am not even getting worked up)@yojik, INTJ would be my second choice but I really just think his tendency to act out and be confrontational is a product of his personality, and that isn't well explained by INTJ. Even if not directly tested, public voting can provide good accuracy regarding Edward Elric Myers-Briggs and personality type!. I am okay with private backups too btw. I just looked at and highlighted some of the ones on edges (I certainly could go on). How could Ed as an ENTJ such* strong Fi. I really can't help but say: ORLY. The second letter in the personality type acronym corresponds to the preference within the sensing-intuition dimension: “S” stands for sensing and “N” stands for intuition.. He's fairly cold towards people despite caring a lot about them, and never engages in any form of Fe-talk (unlike, say Winry). If you don't believe me I can cite a specific chapter of Myers' Gifts Differing. You are "opening a second front," hoping to win there. it also looks like our car is tumbling off the road, which I thought initially led to a consensus on Ed's type. The majority of people are WRONG. ----------------------------. INTPs are well known for their brilliant theories and unrelenting logic, which makes sense since they are arguably the most logical minded of all the personality types.. I could care less about that stuff. Hah- true, now that I'm watching it again. Also to ILIntp, I don't believe in Fe or Fi being indicative at all of MBTI type. His sense of morality is very personal and independent with how he's bullheaded and doesn't care about society's way of feeling. ENTP + 6w7 Sx/So. I think it all gets down to how we are going to type, and different methods of typing yielding different results. Not entj: the whole page has been me shutting down your entj idea and making you upset, don't make me repeat myself. "I don't believe in Fe or Fi being indicative at all of MBTI type" I rest my point with what you just said, (that's basically the foundation of modern MBTI. I certainly don't mind bringing in another point as ILIntp said (and I could), but you are going to get even more confrontational as you haven't gotten your way via route1, nor route2, and I know route3 is not going to go your way either. That's where you could ask for information. It actually reinforces ENTJ cause he's so focused on his work. and make the promise scotty. "I only said sporty, not most* sporty. It`s easier for him to take the risk and hope he survives than consider what happens once he kills the enemy. He's definitely borderline on the I/E axis, but I'd still see him as an introvert. I believe the model is a crude way to describe the functions of 16 different patterns of healthy cognition. I'd guess an NFJ based on the storyDo you think the author herself is an ENTP. Here you can explore of famous people and fictional characters.. With Fe towards his brother of course. He's both extroverted and commanding/decisive. What are his Fi moments. I see him more of a Ti-user than a Te-user. It's not like ENTJ have to be completely serious. Your framework: too goofy *shrugs*Well if you really think that ENTP or INTJ are better fits than ENTJ you should at least be able to explain why. But Ed's Se seems more natural like it's a part of him. One all-but-orphaned kid and his armor suit brother surrounded by a ton of adults. Especially a 13 yr old one. " People thought YOU were trolling. Jung also proposed that in a person one of the four functions above is dominant – either a function of perception or a function of judging.. I doubt it cause he's ultra directed. Watching that for 10 seconds is enough. All of the ENTPs I have met distrust people. I am literally speaking within the framework you established and using those as rules that can't be broken to make this talk possible. net/fs71/i/2010/355/4/b/many_faces_of_edward_elric_2_by_brokensilhouette77-d35dlg2. Would you have rather I used any other episode. I don't want to get banned for just talking about my interests (mbti)You're taking too long, and even in chess world championships you don't get that long. pngThe animators' representation of emotions is goofy for all characters. A lot of NTJs are close to NFJ and thus use Fe more than Fi. I can see it too. truly, you know what I'd like to see you talk about: whether he uses Fe or Fi. Cause ENTJ's Se-tert is the highest preference in all the types with votes. Counterphobic Sixes don't like to be played with, which is what happens to Ed all the time, but he can still defend that he won't take a life and that's one choice he has control of and can sleep in peace with. and he has a scientific approach to life. org/wiki/Pigeon_chessand you promise not to get so confrontational when you lose again. Edward enjoys a lot of leeway in the story thanks to being an Alchemist and the protagonist of the series, not to mention being surrounded by particularly mature adults. it's getting you worked up over nothingNo, you're just posting the same irrelevant crap over and over and trying to pass it off as an argument against a straw man. IMO that has more to do with him being a Six. Speed Gavroche is the most prolific poster here who speaks French, but he doesn't care about animehttp://mbti. Well, talking of your ideas, Edward is definitely a Fi-user. But it's been a while since I've seen it. It's just an illustration of how things maybe ideally should work in a healthy Fe-dom but let me tell you I can't even type myself and the 4-function model only compounds that further. I've always seen him more in his mind than his surroundings. Ed is full force ahead, get that shit done. I'd also like to agree with the notion that the majority could be wrong in typing Ed as an ENTP, by the way. *shrug*I have no interest in playing a game with you and following some sort of rules. I am ready whenever scotty promises not to get so confrontational when he lose again. I could have referred to a different episode, but I just meant I didn't have to go very far to refute your 'loves works' narrative. Well, I argued for that but your reason could be something else. You are in the best place to test MBTI and learn what type Edward Elric likely is!. Says the guy who says "INTP and ESFJ have the same functions, so it's easy to see how someone could get them confused, but it's pretty obvious he prioritizes Fe above Ti because he's not a douchebag, and Si above Ne because he's not crazy. On extremely extremely serious note, I bring up http://www. They could've shown smoke coming out of his ears. Just this: Why would I commit to something I don't believe in. I think he's afraid to kill, it's a dark path he doesn't know and doesn't want to be trapped in. When I say "the ENTJ model" I mean Te-Ni-Se-Fi. Is it weird that I can see him as an INTP. He is seen as an ENTP by a large democratic majority on here, and if you google search a very neutral "Edward Elric mbti" your results are even more staggering ENTP-filled. You want no rules, lol sigh. You're so desperate to play the part of the pigeon in pigeon chess, when I'm not even playing a game. He's an ENTJ by both the letters and Jungian version of MBTI and your attempts to argue against that using silly face art style is laughable. I don't come in here with an one-type-agenda, I just want the truth. The only reason I can think of for such a bias to N vs S in Ed vs Gon, is that one is supposed to be "smart" and one isn't so much. Any one of us speak passable French. and I simply quote you "NTJs like Ed aren't [goofy]". The ENTJ suggestion is interesting, although he seems to have very strong Fi compared to what you'd expect from this type, don't you think. Nvm, you ignored my hunch below. "Fi" more than "Fe" but* here's the evidence. An INTJ would act out a lot less and be more careful. Is he introverted or extroverted. Look at what happens when people take cognitive functions tests. What is the best option for the MBTI type of Edward Elric? What about enneagram and other personality types?. Welcome to MBTIBase - PersonalityBase, here you can learn about Edward Elric MBTI type.. When did I say he was ENTP or INTJ. Okay, but (and this is no longer just* being drawn goofily) Ed literally thinks/daydreams goofy lol http://b1969d. so I was gone for a bit and now that I'm back the first thing I'd like to say is that from where I'm standing it looks like BOTH i and scotty are getting pretty worked up at the moment. It's a very rough model which works for some and not for others. Most of what I remember is him being in deep Ti moments, though I may not be remembering correctly. How's that for a handicap. A) you're not going to get banned here (nobody even moderates this site) B) I have not retracted once. I honestly don’t get the ENTP votes, can someone give an explanation. Why would you think ENTP or INTJ and not ENTJ or INTP.
. He's a kid, and most of time his doesn't know what the hell he's getting himself into. Ed doesn't have particularly strong Fi, but it's stronger than his Fe. mbti-databank. Less subjective, more room to find evidence. He is definitely more extroverted. I really think he is an ENFP or even ESFP.
The new website will come out in ~10 days (hopefully before New Year), and meanwhile Im collecting money for the server,
so please excuse the excessive ads for a while. Also Happy Christmas and New Year, although I gotta be working. Thank you for supporting the development!
Category: Anime and Manga Characters
Series/Domain: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood