Gandalf Myers-Brigs type - MBTI, enneagram and personality type info
But I agree that Gandalf the Grey is more P than Gandalf the White. Finally someone who sees Grey as INTP and White as INTJ. Gandalf stops paying attention to Saruman because he knows that the dwarves are leaving while the White Council deliberates and knows that the blade is a Morgul blade, thus having no need to listen to Saruman's droning. I agree with you there. Seems like a fully matured INFJ that can actually use their Ti and Se. Discover Array, and more, famous people, fictional characters and celebrities here!. You are in the best place to test MBTI and learn what type Gandalf likely is!. Gandalf is more balanced and is on the side of good but they're both logical, sincere, and self-centered, and neither modify what they say for the sake of outer ethics and group harmony.
. So everything that seems Ni is actually Ne. See this is what I mean by people arbitrarily shapi g what each type can be and the definitions of functions, etc. Gandalf told him, "You won't make it. "lol @Debaser. i don't know if it's cute or just pathetic He seems INTP for more of the storyline than INTJ, but he is never INFJ. This is the problem with functions. When the dwarves refuse to go to Rivendell, Gandalf leads them there without their knowledge, because he knows, for the plan to work, he needs to get Elrond to read the map. He is about as INTP as it gets. Also, when tempted by the Ring, Gandalf doesn't show external signs of temptation but merely shouts "Don't tempt me, Frodo. He somehow lacks the warmth and humanity of the Grey. I don't see him as particularly goal-focused, certainly not beyond the capability of an old, wise INTP. Representative Exemples are based on the number of vote , not on ratioWhy the hell does the home page list Gandalf as an INTP example when the votes weigh in favor of INTJ. " and then explains to Frodo calmly why he cannot take it. Ni types are actually usually much more direct and concerned with reality than their Ne counterparts, especially the introverts. Ni is all "P", thus INJs aren't as J as you might think. His entire demeanor, how he interacts, particularly with the hobbits, and every action he takes and everything he says. Saruman seemingly was motivated by his fear of loss of power - or something like that. Thus he is an INTP, not INTJ. " Not concretely saying Gandalf is an INFJ, but I see a lot of Ni, and I would say the argument for INFJ is more plausible and compelling than the credit given to it. If anything I would say Js are less strong willed on average as they are more likely to turn to external rules and structure for guidance and concede to external standards of judgement. Remember, Saruman is biased against Radagast and refuses to accept his testimony that the sword is a Morgul blade, while Gandalf trusts Radagast's judgment and can see for himself that the blade is indeed a Morgul blade. It's like saying that everything that seems Si is Se. Gandalf is an ESFP. Whereas Gandalf wasn't as convinced and instead chose to assist whatever Middle Earth forces wanted to stop the forces of evil as a wise but seemingly lowly Wizard. For example, here's your comments on the Gandalf/Bilbo thing with different explanations: "In one scene in the hobbit (3rd movie towards the end), Bilbo volunteered to travel across the battlefield to warn the dwarves of somrthing. Compare to Galadriel (INFJ). I believe Gandalf is a Je type and a sure introvert. I would think his drive and vision and then his attempt to fulfill the vision. He takes things as they come. @jlee-blue: I like that heuristic. I'd say he's a Ti user considering he's taken so long in diving deep into some knowledge, probably Ne got him distracted by the archives of Gondor, lol. He's not unstructured or particularly relaxed; he's structured and tenacious. But in the movies, Gandalf is clearly shown to be basically the opposite of Bilbo, and the P/J divide is the clearest difference between the two. @Wh1skey: What's your definition of Fe. If they are on the good side like Elrond they tend to have Si instead of Ni. Gandalf is not warm, fuzzy, or overly emotional. Ne is constantly being mistaken as Ni just because guess what, Ne can manifest itself as one big idea. This is true of INFJs who may appear tactless; the Ni is so strong that Fe can be overshadowed by the pressure of an "inner vision. True but I could invert that argument to make the exact same case for a more adaptable INTJ. Better, but I still completely disagree that Gandalf THE GREY is more of a planner than an improviser. Gandalf the White seems INTJ. I was certain when I made this comment but now I can’t remember why. Do not be a fool, Bilbo, if you can help it. Definitely more Ti/Fe than Te/Fi in this form. His communication is the opposite of that Te conciseness. It's hilarious that some philosophers come up with singular concepts and somehow that becomes proof of "Ni" to the community here. For all his bluster and occasional rage, Gandalf isn’t very controlling and likes to keep his options open perhaps a little too much. But they're excellent insights into someone's inner workings and motivations. And Gandalf's contrast to the clearly INTJ Saruman only drives this home. The White may be a different story, I'm not so sure. Its part of why the character is sort of a fun take on the Merlin archetype, but It’s also part of the reason why the fate of Middle Earth becomes the responsibility of a couple of Hobbits in the first place. I actually sort of think Gandalf’s biggest character flaw comes from his strongly perceiving nature. INTJs won't necessarily be domineering in a leadership position, they'll just be focused on the goal/vision above all else and will strive for it in a logical, objective, impersonal manner. The P/J dichotomy is most erroneously used again and again. " Gandalf uses his Fe to trust his word. Why Te-Fi over Fe-Ti. The answer is none. If that's not strong willed, absolutely nothing is. He’s largely reactive, not proactive. If they hold any use at all, it is only as a tool for breakdown and further reflection AFTER one has already determined their type through proper means. And by the same logic as offered below, could I not say that Gandalf is "more J than you might think" because his "dominant function" Ti is a "introverted judging function. And that quote I posted. INTJ and INFJ are much more grounded than their INTP and INFP counterparts who are huge dreamers and philosophers. It's not like INTP's are incapable of planning. This is indicative of Si. Especially if you try to understand to the moral landscape Tolkien might've been trying to paint. " And "All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us. Seriously what. They were never ever ever intended to be (ab)used this way. And Gandalf the White's lower Fi naturally implies higher Te, and vice versa for Grey, which is why White appears more "J" and less warm than Grey despite them both being INTJ. Everything about Gandalf the Grey points to INTP in my book. There's only 16 different types and a ton of different personalities, so comparing him to Galadriel isn't exactly fair. Hence, his occasional outbursts at Bilbo. Now, maybe Gandalf became a bit more J like Sauroman when he became the White, but as the Grey. Jung also proposed that in a person one of the four functions above is dominant – either a function of perception or a function of judging.. He's not a total dick, but he's still an INTJ. The difference between Gandalf and Saruman is not F vs. In the book he took like 20+ years to learn about the ring of power. And some that die deserve life. INTJ not INFJ. It's about how it is done, not what is done. I see him as very unstructured and rather relaxed. INTPs can be quite stubborn and refuse to allow themselves to be pushed into anything by anyone and stand firm on their (logical) principles no matter what. As a Guardian Angel, Gandalf sorta plays it fast and loose. got it Gandalf is an INTJ. Therefore not an INTJ. Lincoln's leadership style was different from Gandalf's, at least from what I know of Lincoln and what I've said about Gandalf. Noticeably stronger presence of Fe over Fi because of his acceptance of a variety of cultures; also, he is a likable individual, naturally able to get along with others. seems pretty INTJ to me. If you don't then I can see how you'd get more INTJ. Well, for starters, in The Desolation of Smaug it is revealed that Gandalf, not Thorin, was the person who started the quest for Erebor. Ah, so not only did it enhance his wardrobe and magical ability but also his personality. To find out what your MBTI personality type is you need to complete the MBTI questionnaire and take part in a feedback session from a qualified MBTI practitioner.. A healthy INTJ. Though he may change the tactics as complications arise, the overall plan remains exactly the same: get to Erebor. Gandalf is an Ni dominant, no hint of Ne. I used my Ti-Ne to see a good possibility with good chances of you making it and surviving, and failed to see it. " Here's a by-the-letters argument for you: Gandalf's an INT, clearly, and a J because he's more of a planner than an improviser. Stripped down of all things else Gandalf's preference is for Ni-Te. INTJ 1w9 so/sx. As for your comment about keeping a stronger watch over them, in Bilbo's journey he had to leave in order to investigate the Dol Guldur fortress. It's always made more sense to me to type Grey and White separately. When he's forced to go through the mines of Moria, he shows very weak Se/Te, not being able to adapt his plans to reality. Nothing more can be said regarding this fictional character's "functions" (an absurdity in itself) that can be even close to accurate or consistent or that I couldn't rip a hole in to argue Gandalf is in fact ESFP. Internal judgers temper their theories in personalized judgment, while extroverted judgers temper them in a more collective judgment. He may have ethics but that tertiary Fi gives that and I have seen it in other INTJs as well. I wonder, though: if you exclude every time Gandalf changes the plan due to something out of his control, how many times does he adapt the plan at all. Gandalf is simply not one. Don't waste your time writing about how this fictional wizard's dominant function is "Ni" and how because in this instance it is in favor of your argument even though in another it might not be, that means he is really a J who just happens to act like a P. However when we have to vote we should look for best fit. But the point still stands: Gandalf, grey or white, always does have a plan and is prepared to do nearly anything to execute it. The best that can be said about Gandalf is that, for the reasons I explained, his behavior is generally more consistent with the definition of a type who predominantly extroverts perceiving rather than judging. Were they watching the same movies I was. " before refusing it. And he just seems to use Ti and not Te, understanding the world through logic primarily, except for maybe in his reborn form he could be an INTJ. INTJs are Ni doms too, so they can have "mystical intuitiveness" just like INFJs. He prefers to influence others in their decision-making by providing information. They just prefer less rigid plans that allow for spontaneous adjustment. INFPs, like most introverts, are quiet and reserved. They prefer not to talk about themselves.. He got captured and imprisoned in the process. You're always hilarious when you type character you like as INFJ because you think being one. They do have a lot of the same sarcastic mannerisms. Welcome to MBTIBase - PersonalityBase, here you can learn about Gandalf MBTI type.. I mean yeah he's completely reborn. Loyal to their peers and to their internal value systems, but not overly concerned with respecting laws and rules if they get in the way of getting something done. Detached and analytical, they excel at finding solutions to practical problems.. Can you give it to them. Even if not directly tested, public voting can provide good accuracy regarding Gandalf Myers-Briggs and personality type!. you can't make it. " How much more INTP can it get. But in The Hobbit and Fellowship, he is definitely an INTP. Like Anakin and Vader have different types too. It just doesn't get more P than Gandalf the Grey. An INTJ with stronger Ni/weaker Te than most would be like this. Thinking – Feeling, represents how a person processes information. Thinking means that a person makes a decision mainly through logic.. I settled for INTJ when I recall his battle mode, which is kind of Se. If you enjoyed this entry, find out about the personality types of Lord of The Rings characters list.. Pretty much, yeah, Khel. While he can use Ne to foresee a variety of possibilities of a situation, he lets others make decisions. Of course this is just a general correlation but it makes true in theory and based off observations of real people. Quiet, reflective, and idealistic. Interested in serving humanity. Well-developed value system, which they strive to live in accordance with.. Well I'm including The Hobbit as part of the storyline. ") It all screams INTP. I can understand the INTP argument from a by-the-letters perspective but I can't see INFJ at all. Just contrast him with Dumbledore. Te relies on data/empirical induction while Ti on principles/deductions. They can be twisted to mean anything you want them to and argue anything and write off opposing evidence by pointing to some ridiculous function loophole that does not exist and was not ever intended as part of the theory. Though his plan evolves as the journey continues, it's still always in place and every big decision he makes furthers that plan. In one scene in the hobbit (3rd movie towards the end), Bilbo volunteered to travel across the battlefield to warn the dwarves of somrthing. An INTJ would have kept a much stronger watch over Frodo and Bilbo's journeys and actively reigned them in. No, I think that even if functions weren't total pseudoscience (which they totally are) and even if they were intended to be used as typing tools according to the original theory (which they totally weren't), Gandalf the Grey still fits "Ne" better - that is to say, he extroverts his intuition and perceiving. This bites him HARD when he realizes that the ring Bilbo has is The One Ring, and effectively has to scramble for a last minute solution. "Natural" maybe is better. It might be hard but one can somewhat make out the Fe based motivations of Gandalf seeing his choice to protect the welfare of Middle Earth over succumbing to his fear of weakness. So though he has some P qualities, overall he's a J. That being said I've had him as INTP for a while now. Where are you even seeing Fe in him. Well, if anything is evidence of "Ti," that right there is it. Te is as logical as Ti. They do seem quite a like. Gandalf failed to use Ni-Te to see a possibility where Bilbo can make it. That sort of mystical intuitiveness, and his interaction methods - can't be anything but INFJ. There's no evidence of actual spontaneity or indecision. The real INTJ is Saruman. Not much of a planner at all. I think it's true for any type: the stronger the dominant, the weaker the auxiliary. I'd also argue that Gandalf exhibits a different type of "strong will" than the one you just described for INTPs. When recalling information, he consults his data of stored knowledge to reinforce his Ti-Ne possibilities. The way he just changes plans on the fly and wanders off. Are you going to tell me that the greatest leader in US history, INTP Abraham Lincoln, was also an INTJ for this reason. He lets things happen, then reacts to them via intuition. He's not 100% J but leans that way, even if only slightly. He has a ton of power but is very modest and really doesn't try to shape the world apart from when strong circumstances arise. But those two types are less likelier than INTJ in my opinion. Drawing an arbitrary line as to "how J" a type should be because of a ridiculous concept that everyone prefers 4 vaguely defined symbols that are never supposed to be used to type people according to one of 16 fixed "orders" is ridiculous. I think that while he certainly gives off that vibe and thus probably is INTx letter-by-letter he actually does try to shape the world in grand ways. It's all relative and typing loses all meaning when you do it that way. Not the way it's supposed to work. Many of the things you explain away with Fe are not at all beyond Fi. Woah and since when are INTPs not strong willed. That way, I can defend my typings whether I'm talking to a "Keirseyan" or a "functions-user. And let us not forget "A wizard is never late, nor is he early. He arrives precisely when he means to. In this site you can find out which of the 16 types this character 'Gandalf' belongs to!. Here you can explore of famous people and fictional characters.. The Grey seams INTPish to me (indecisive, not a very good planner, not always straightforward in his communication style etc), while The White is one of the best INTJ example that comes to mind. What is the best option for the MBTI type of Gandalf? What about enneagram and other personality types?. He's wiser and more powerful but noticeably less whimsical and solely focused on the outcome. But he's also tenacious, strong-willed, and very comfortable in a leading role. The book goes into great detail on how different he is. He kinda have that INTP look and humor first. So from the start, Gandalf had a clear vision and plan in mind: to collect a group of dwarves, a burglar (who he picked before Bilbo even knew about the quest), and send them to obtain the Arkenstone and unite the dwarves. " Seriously, how do so many people think Gandalf is a J. I'd say that most famous philosophers of the last few centuries are actually INxP despite getting typed as INxJ because of supposed "Ni". Same goes for ISTPs and IxFPs. Now, I definitely agree that the troll-ish quote about "good morning" is extremely INTPish, but that's very small evidence that doesn't preclude J by itself. I think he's an INTP. If we just keep saying "INTPs can make grand plans too" and "INTJs can adapt plans too" then we won't get anywhere. " Bilbo firmly replied with "I can do it. Too many Te-Fi types (Sauron and Saruman) on the side of the bad guys. You have no evidence whatsoever for Gandalf being an "Ni" type or preferring to extrovert judging. Because he's a villain lmao. Far easier for the healthy INTP to exist which is why he comes across as one. Yes I see more INTJ in him than anything else as well. On the other hand, I don't see much Fi with the White. And yes, INTJs are 100% J as much as any other J types, and INTPs are as P as any other P type. I just see him more on the Fe/Ti axis. For Gandalf, he's strong-willed in that the plan and goal comes first above all else, while INTPs are strong-willed in that they won't budge unless they deem it necessary to.
. The entire point of The Hobbit is to contrast Gandalf's very P lifestyle to Bilbo's very J lifestyle and show how Gandalf gave him a sense of adventure and whimsy. we can see the 1 integrate to 7"No, no no no. His frustration kind of reminds me of Locke (Lost). He's hard to type considering him being a Maiar and have lived for like 1000+ years. I used my Ni-Te to project into the future and imagine a scenario with good chances of you making it and surviving, and failed to see it. The following quote is literally the most INTP thing ever said: "What do you mean. Therefore not an INFJ. He pays little to no regard to schedules and rules and he changes plans on a whim. Grey, however, seems more INFJ/INTP tbh. I will just laugh. You're a close friend of mine and I cannot afford to lose you. From his beard to his clothes to his laid back demeanor to his fireworks. Some INTJs may have stronger judging preferences than others. I actually think that Ni vs Ne is extremely misunderstood. When he is with the group, he's actually pretty focused and structured and leads them assertively. To give an example, when Bilbo told Gandalf that Bilbo lost the ring, Gandalf knew he was lying, but let him keep it because he could tel that Bilbo badly desired to keep it. Therefore not an INFJ. IxxP types in general are fiercely independent and very strong willed.
The new website will come out in ~10 days (hopefully before New Year), and meanwhile Im collecting money for the server,
so please excuse the excessive ads for a while. Also Happy Christmas and New Year, although I gotta be working. Thank you for supporting the development!
Category: Movie Characters
Series/Domain: Lord of The Rings