George Carlin Myers-Brigs type - MBTI, enneagram and personality type info
Drawing arbitrary lines between them as Celebrity Types does is ridiculous. If you enjoyed this entry, find out about the personality types of Acting and Movie Industry characters list.. I disagree that if CT said Carlin was an ISTJ, this site would have him as one. If I'm allowed to mention multiple types, he's on the borderline between ENTP and ENTJ. I'll do it the Celebrity Types (who most certainly do type by using functions behaviorally, in spite of what they say) way:. They do not exist. Cognitive functions are best viewed as the abstravt inner workings of a type, not how the type actually manifests. We could shoot quotes and disputes over "Fe" and "Fi" all day, neither with any proof of their existence or meaning or presence in a person, and get nowhere. I don't owe you an explanation. Intuitives focus on a more abstract level of thinking; they are more interested in theories, patterns, and explanations. They are often more concerned with the future than the present and are often described as creative. Celebrity Types doesn't get all of its typings correct and I frequently disagree with them but they're a respectable site and don't even use the functions behavioristically. "Inside every cynical person, there is a disappointed idealist" - Carlin. You can indeed reject them entirely. If that is your reason for him not being an "F" then you ground is weak. He seems to be quite introverted compared to some other comedians but I still think he tips to the E side. And ISTJ isn't even as implausible for Freud as it would be for Carlin. "But while Hicks and Maher delight in pointing out logical inconsistencies, Carlin delights in pointing out moral fallacies and the flawed motivations of others. Could also be a dark/depressed ENTP (think of Cleese), but somehow he isn't animated enough. It bothers me that everyone seemed to agree that Carlin was ENTP before CT said otherwise, and now they all say he is ENFP instead because of group think. But I would say Carlin definitely did the former more. It is too easy to argue any of them or for them to contradict each other. Look at the weak quotes they give for "evidence" on their ENTP page and then ask yourself why they say Carlin isn't ENTP. "The reason I talk to myself is that I'm the only one whose answers I accept. INFJs are visionaries and idealists who ooze creative imagination and brilliant ideas.. He uses simple, concrete, literal language to get this point across. On second thought could he actually be ENTJ. " This shows that Carlin, like many ISTJs, is plagued by a kind of stubbornness brought on by the Si-Te combination. I would guess that if Celebrity Types said Carlin was an ISTJ, ISTJ would be winning this vote right now. CelebrityTypes insists he's a feeler by comparing him with Bill Hicks but I think the reality is that Carlin was just older and wiser than Bill. So if you enjoy being wrong and buying into Celebrity Type's BS, by all means vote ENFP. " That would be absurd. But the MBTI is not an exact science anyway so both interpretations have merit. Try saying Carlin's an ISTJ and Hicks is an ISFJ. But in regards to the inconsistency criticism, I challenge anyone to find an example of an ENTP on their ENTP page who actually fits every trait on Carlin's side—including the "avoids engaging audiences' critical faculties" trait. They are willing to set them aside and make people uncomfortable and upset to say what they think is the truth. Please enlighten me with how "logical" beings attempt to type as you made me realise how wrong I've been to concern myself with cognitive functionsBut where is your argument. All three did both regularly. He didn't whine about people doing the wrong thing and were immoral. If you must use these things that do not exist as symbols, keep them out of typing and only do it afterwards. Consider Freud. Listen to his bit on "soft language" just off the top of my head. ENTP I think, slight chance ENFPcelebrity type are expert shut up if you are nothing of interest to say#fg, don't know if you're a troll or CT pays you by commentknow your FONCTION he is fi-te not ti-fe so he is ENFP feeler vs thinker is bullshit for child. Repeating that he is a quintessential ENTP doesn't make him one. I could much more easily see INTP even actually. All of them push buttons and say things that no type who prefers feeling would say. And I am certain that if they said Bill Hicks was the ENFP and Carlin the ENTP, ENTP would be winning for Carlin and ENFP would be winning for Hicks. It is 100% pseudo-logic that takes picked cherries out of context and twists them to fit an agenda. The thinking preference is probably his strongest. George Carlin is probably an ENFP despite cynical behavior; all of his cynicism comes from disillusionment, not noticing and getting angry with a lack of logic. And if you actually vote for ENFP you deserve to have your typing license taken away. I don't know where the F votes are coming from. You'd have almost no evidence to make those claims. Free in-depth and practical information on the 16 personality types, including careers and relationships.. " This joke clearly demonstrates Carlin's dominant Si. His judging can be pretty ruthless and extroverted. I have argued this subject a couple times before and am sick of it. I find him very similar with Charles Bukowski, and I think both are ENTP 6w5ENTP > INTP > everything else. An ENFP would have gentler, softer comedy that is less critical. Quintessential ENTP. You can see and test for clear preferences Iin the real world. Dismissing something just because you don't agree with it and not giving ample reason is absurd. "Some people see things that are and ask, Why. Carlin is cynical because he thinks people are stupid and irrational, which is obvious when you listen to him for five minutes. Watch "The planet is fine" monologue on environmentalism. INFPs, like most introverts, are quiet and reserved. They prefer not to talk about themselves..
. Jung theorized that the dominant function acts alone in its preferred world: exterior for extraverts and interior for introverts.. We aren't saying "because he has convictions, he's an Fi type and therefore ENFP. I changed my vote from ENFP to ENTP. The Cliffnotes is that MBTI tests by following Occam's Razor: That is, preferences. In fact that's like the whole appeal of his comedy. They all have the same basic personality. That's not how it works and it's not how you type. The CelebrityTypes admin typed him as ENFP because he thought it would make him look clever. But while Hicks and Maher delight in pointing out logical inconsistencies, Carlin delights in pointing out moral fallacies and the flawed motivations of others. Using cognitive functions behavioristically is a bad idea, but for explaining motivations for behavior, they have considerable importance. So not everyone on this site is a CT sheep. ) He also shows Te in his emphasis on time management. He isn't afraid to ask and say things that most NF types would not, if only for the sake of politeness and harmony. There is practically no difference between the deliveries of Carlin, Bill Hicks, Bill Maher, etc. No he does not "ave" Fi. Discover Array, and more, famous people, fictional characters and celebrities here!. But I'm sure fewer people would buy into that than would buy into an ENxP type. Celebrity Types is a horrid site and that "convincing" comparison is anything but. Hahaha I have to give you credit: that was very funny and yet there probably would be people who would buy into it. Some people dream of things that never were and ask, Why not. But his Fi helps explain why he's so cynical. So no, him being an F type is not a joke and not entirely out of question. Carlin told it like it is and had no time for morals and niceties. He refuses to consider the ideas and perspectives of others; he only accepts his own conclusions as valid, demonstrating a kind of black and white thinking validated by tertiary Fi. You may not agree with those distinctions, and that's fine; whether they're true distinctions between Fi and Ti is debatable (I happen to see their point). Welcome to MBTIBase - PersonalityBase, here you can learn about George Carlin MBTI type.. ) on their flawed motivations. No way he has anything to do with ENFP. Even if not directly tested, public voting can provide good accuracy regarding George Carlin Myers-Briggs and personality type!. There's something about him which just doesn't quite match with any type. " Carlin here clearly shows a conflict between his inferior Ne and his dominant Si. Arguing anything else, especially an F type, is absurd and wrong. You are in the best place to test MBTI and learn what type George Carlin likely is!. Anyway, for Carlin, he does have the same "basic personality" as Hicks and Maher; they're both ENxPs. He is observing a trend based on previously gathered sensory data that indicates to him that the night will be dark because previous nights were also dark. He is the quintessential ENTP. There's room for multiple interpretations of the MBTI, (which you obviously agree with because you DO think for yourself and reject parts of other people's interpretations) and mine happens to not reject the functions while yours does. Just complete bullshit. Carlin has a strong preference for thinking over feeling. He makes logical arguments and is very hard and insensitive to deelings. The second letter in the personality type acronym corresponds to the preference within the sensing-intuition dimension: “S” stands for sensing and “N” stands for intuition.. And if its not how it works, please enlighten how it does. For now it just seems that are being stubborn about what you think is right and not providing any reason as to why. Honestly, I'm not even sure if he'd test as a T. Celebrity Types is a garbage site deserving of no respect. And Carlin's cynical behaviour and his wits discards him as an NF altogether. If you can think logically for yourself, vote ENTP. In this case, they have a strong case for Carlin as ENFP, and I agree with it. If anything, Jon Stewart, who Celebrity Types has as ENTP, comes far closer to talking more about "moral fallacies" than logical inconsistencies than Carlin ever did. How is he not Fi amd Fe. "Weather forecast for tonight: Dark. I cannot accept ENFP as a consensus, when he is CLEARLY a thinker. He's not as preoccupied with logic and the impersonal as he appears. You can't just reject them entirely. That quote proves nothing and his being an F is completely out of question. Some people have to go to work and don't have time for all that. grow up and take the good trainAlso, the differences they show between Carlin and Hicks are subtle but not arbitrary. Here you can explore of famous people and fictional characters.. Well, it just made him look arrogant, stupid, and inconsistent. In this site you can find out which of the 16 types this character 'George Carlin' belongs to!. By that logic you can condone every immoral act because the offender thinks he knows better. It is impossible to say that someone "has" an abstract notion known as a cognitive function based on their behavior and words. That is obvious merely from watching him and listening to him. In fact, in that monologue, he skips over many places where he could have made impersonal logical arguments but never misses an opportunity to call out the people (environmentalists/etc. There's probably a few people who just vote for whatever CT suggests, but there are also people who do think for themselves and try to only make informed claims. And I don't think you could twist quotes to fit any type. What is the best option for the MBTI type of George Carlin? What about enneagram and other personality types?. I am not disagreeing you just for the sake of it, I'm curious what's behind your choice, what's the reasoning. Yes he does do both but he's not 100% F just like Hicks/Maher are not 100% T.
. It's definitely not true that people do not think for themselves on this site at all. The entire point of that monologue is to point out the moral fallacies and flawed motivations of others. Though his comedy routines are much more tipped toward thinking (Ti) than intuition (Ne), unlike Stewart and Colbert. ENPs are Ne doms and Si inferior so the only thing left discussing is their T and F functions. He pointed out how stupid they were. But calling everyone who disagrees with ENTP for Carlin "people who don't think for themselves" is kind of hypocritical. So he could maybe be an ENTP but ENFP is not out of the question and, to me, seems more likely; in general, T types are more concerned with logic/impersonal truths while F types are more concerned with sentiment/values, and Carlin seems to be more the latter. Not because of the nonexistent "Fi," which does not make a person cynical anyway even according to theory. " They have no case whatsoever for Carlin as ENFP, and I am certain he would not test as such. People do not think for themselves on this site. It is a scam that promotes pseudoscience and confidently claims to know things it does not and cannot and contradicts evidence and logic and then charges you for its "expertise. The 23 ENFP votes are worse than spam. See: Jimmy Fallon. CT has him as ISTJ, but there are only 3 votes for ISTJ while there are 14 votes for ENTJ and 4 votes for ESTJ. I could do the same thing to argue anyone is any type. You are one of them. The Te-Fi sharpshooting is more indicative of INTJ (if I stretch it, he could also even be ENTJ). They do not value harmony, morality and people above rationality at all. Celebritytypes has done a convincing comparison of Hicks and Carlin. Alright, I'll take your challenge to argue Carlin as ISTJ. Although subconsciously curious about exploring new ideas and possibilities, he ultimately sides with sticking to conventional ways (I.
Hello, Im finally done with A LOT of IRL trouble, so the new site (PersonalityBase) will be finally comming soon.
I hope it will be good enough to make up for the time. I apologize for the inconvenience. But hmmm lets be optimistic.
Category: Acting and Movie Industry
TOTAL MBTI VOTES: 41
ENTP - 21 vote(s)
ENFP - 20 vote(s)
TOTAL ENNEA VOTES: 10
6W5 - 9 vote(s)
6W7 - 1 vote(s)