Luna Lovegood Myers-Brigs type - MBTI, enneagram and personality type info
She definitely isn't an archetypal INFP. The type can't change and it is their natural inclination to be like this so it is a piece of who they are) Often a person's enneagram type corresponds quite a bit to their myers briggs type (which describes their naturally preferred way of functioning) the relationship between their myers briggs and enneagram types also seems to conflict in some situations. It's so opposite to her behaviour. Even 5s have less patience for BS than her. Somehow the most known characters interested in those creatures are Newt Scamander and Hagrid, both also typed as Fi-doms (in real life that could be called a coincidence, in fiction it could be called author's intention to highlight ethical significance of taking care of animals or nature in general). Who says INTP's are not inclined to say moderately warm things. She reminds me of an INTP friend too but I'm not basing my judgement on that (it might make me a bit biased though ^^). ” (remember when she closed dobby's eyes after he died. The arguments in favour of INTP are so strong and convincing and totally reliant on Jungian theory that I can't even take part with my limited knowledge. To me the Fi is very evident. Te inferior is visible because she generally struggles with demands of being practical, assertive and orderly, however during battles or other critical situations her determination and focus on getting things done when they need to be done is noticable (of course after those situations she comes back to being dreamy). I agree with Klkatykat. Luna is not guided by doing the right thing(Fi) but more by harmony (Fe). A bit lonely without the DA. This wasn't plotting against him but could even be considered sympathizing. Because if it's just you alone you're not as much of a threat. They are intuitive and have dom Fe. HAVE YOU MET AN INTP BEFORE. ” (remember when she closed dobby's eyes after he died. ” “He says very funny things sometimes, doesn’t he. Heathcliff understands as "undifferent", "cold", "no connection", "don't care" "not intense" is not something that describes INFPs or INTPs in this case, but Nines: "Nines demonstrate the universal temptation to ignore the disturbing aspects of life and to seek some degree of peace and comfort by “numbing out. I'll grant you that quotes alone don't determine type. "If she had Fe she would try to act normal. She appears empty inside while saying random shit. One thing I recognized is, in the books Luna is a lot more defensive about her beliefs. Admin should look into it. Of course, she tries to explain who all the creatures are and how they supposedly act, but behind this explanation there's just her whim, not any serious examination. INTP is a better choice since she uses a lot of Ti. Anyway I can understand the reasoning for the INFP votes at all. and she just don't care for nothing what people say about her and even what they DO with her (like steal her shoes), something that I guess an INFP would give most importance (they can problably does not show this, but will care hardly in core). On another occasion someone said I reminded him of Obama (INTP). You compared her interest in magical creatures to Hagrid's (a Fi dom), but Hagrid only puts his intense passion into existing creatures (and who are barely seen by others), but his interest is far more personal than intellectual. I'm sorry that I can't think of any other fictional intps off the top of my head but a great example of a real figure would be Albert Einstein (Again a logical eccentric)Well of course she's nothing like harry. INTP tritype (9w1 5w4 4w5)I found your analysis very interesting (and long, haha), I can actually understand several points, but I still continue with the Ti-Fe point instead of Fi-Te, assuming that what would be "logical" in the wizarding world is a bit different. It describes what a person wants to become (and are to a sense. She's not interested in what makes sense, she's interested more in what makes value to her, what's she passionate about. Could you use quotation marks when you're quoting someone, instead of pretending that what you write is your own opinion. Night, lets be clear. I think if she was using mostly Ti she would be more critical of The Quibbler that was full of nonsense. Some people call me ‘Loony’ Lovegood, actually. Some people call me ‘Loony’ Lovegood, actually. Ginny’s been nice, though. And he is not so detached of his feelings in general. F means you're guided by values and emotions more so than by logic. INFJ enneagram 3. Luna displays Fi in: personal beliefs (in weird creatures that no one has ever seen), personal tastes (uncool but deliberate clothing etc. They don't want to be normal. She "merges" very easily with people, as if she is comfortable around everyone even though no one is comfortable around her, as if she is always idealizing her surroundings ("people are just having fun while they steal my stuff, no big deal, they give back" vibes). In either case, fictional characters are usually pretty tricky. She says things that causes awkward moments. But neither does anecdotal evidence or one possible INTP who acts like Luna. She's not a five. Luna is to detached from her own feeling to be INFP, and she clearly show Ti against harry she understand harry's emotion whereas harry just feel and doesn't try to rationalize this feelings. INFPs are detached but have alot going on inside. You're just as sane as I am. Not analytical enough to be INTP. Elveni, 10-13-2013 08:46 PM (page 1):. She has no trace of 1 whatsoever, so how do you explain her being a 9w1. And coming from someone who also lost a parent, her response is normal. INFP because only INFPs care about typing her :P. ALMOST EVERYTHING LUNA SAYS IS EMOTIONAL. Both 4w5 and 5w4 have sharper edges and are anxious about their role of outsiders, Luna is anything but anxious and kinda melts away all the time.
. And on yet another occasion someone said I reminded him of Sam Harris (INFJ). She's the posterchild for infp. Contrary to popular belief, INFPs aren't just the dumber version of INTPs. It seems random. Its her weakest function so obviously she will have a lack of understanding of the social realm making her appear kinda blissfully unaware of her actions. Luna takes all the crap and acts like "they're just having fun", the Nine's vice of idealizing life and people. I wonder if she were a boy if it would affect how people see her. Even intp 4s are logical. The 5w4 INTPs are especially good at feeling almost childlike in its purity affection towards friends. And intps don't have that dreamy idealistic aura. Remember Ti isn't just "subjective logic"; it takes impersonal premises and principles and subjects them to logical analysis, often in a deductive and analytical manner. So I guess what mr. You have to understand that for fictional characters you have to type them based on behavior. Not like Luna. April Ludgate is an obvious ISTP. The second letter in the personality type acronym corresponds to the preference within the sensing-intuition dimension: “S” stands for sensing and “N” stands for intuition.. But I still have my father, right. She feels gratified to be part of a group, to have friends and can be usefull to them. she has antisocial traits that is rare amongst INTP's. " She doesn't seem to have a particular connection to anything, save for her interest in magical creatures, which is obviously a more intellectual interest than anything. which is a good argument for her being Fi/Te value/fact internally warm/externally cold axis oriented (you could also make point that it's an argument against her being 9w1, but it's humanly impossible to not get angry from time to time even for 9w1s). Interest in magical creatures being an indicator of Ti. An enneagram 4 infj however has Fe and while they are still emotional like an infp and still have that poetic aura to them they don't have it quite the way an infp would and may wonder why their feelings are directed this way and may even try to mimic Fi. Whoever who voted ESTP was on drugs, lol. Also yes, I would agree that the quote resembles Fi. " (Offended) “I think they think I’m a bit odd, you know. Of all the mbti types, intp seems to embody enneagram 5. ) The infp enneagram 4 pairing barely conflicts at all. A strategic move to defeat Harry Potter. (2) How does that preclude INFP. You are in the best place to test MBTI and learn what type Luna Lovegood likely is!. She is in her own little world. com/guess-type/164727-luna-lovegood-intp-infp. It becomes very obvious when you compare her to Fi dominants like Harry that she isn't one. Have you people even met a female INTP. " "You're being rather rude you know. Everything she says is emotional. -Her logic is precise, absolute, detached, subjective and very stubborn. An infp 5 would try to be emotionally detached and logical but their logic would stray to the emotional side. ” (remember when she closed dobby's eyes after he died. People can resemble other types all the time. He puts his passion when he takes care of these creatures, there is much more feeling than intellectuality in his interest. I don't care what you think. I used other points to back up my belief that she is an INTP. From what i've noticed, intps are aware of this but alot are socially awkward but others are great socially]. The five cuts themselves off from others, feels separate. Grant (ISFP), then. Best explanation about the importance of Feeling and Thinking ever. "Hermione was initially frustrated with Luna's belief in all manner of things without logical grounds or proof. The way how she talks with people come to me most as Inferior Fe than Fi Dom. If you don't know the mbti then don't vote on it. Bryan Griffin (Family Guy). She doesn't use Te for sure. After graduating from Hogwarts:. " But anyway again I see no Ti and a bucketload of Fi. They're not logically sound OR unsound because they're not even logical principles: they're personal, EMOTIONAL principles, a. ) aaaaI'd say INTP, but I can see INFP too. It is Si, detail-oriented but irrational, that desperately tries to back up her galloping Ne, not really Ti that would have to lead her whole decision making process. Obviously there is a trace of it on the outside but an fi-dom would hardly be that confident about their personality and actions or so fast to notice stuff that didn't have so much to do with their identity. " When INTPs say random quirky things, if you analyze what they say it's actually very logical, just unusual. INFP's do not have Ti/Te so therefore they cannot be strategic and come up with moves to defeat people. That's her entire character: she says quirky and eccentric yet inwardly warm and wise little nuggets of emotional sincerity that endear people to her despite her eccentricity. Also by-the-letters Luna is a definite INFP still: highly value-based and emotionally sincere, but not logical. )*Whoops, I meant: Peaceful, "ROMANTIC" contemplative (5-9-4)5-9-4 Tritype- which is the peaceful, reflective "Contemplative". Pretty different, Ti vs Te / Fi vs Te. True she's not exactly like Harry (ISFP) but instead of only comparing her to other IFPs, compare her to INTPs too. Great points Ventus. " it just Te (need for proof) against Ne (fantasies ), you mix inconsistencies (Ti) for need for proof(Te). She stubbornly defends them and does this in a very emotional manner. Well if I were You-Know-Who, I'd want you to feel cut off from everyone else. Yeah she knows that they call her Looney but she could care less. Being the eccentric, dreamy, "Alice Adventures" lookalike girl gives her an INFP vibe, but function-wise Ti makes so much more sense. I see good arguments for both sides, not entirely convinced. Also, I don't think she is a Fi dom at all. How are people typing her as intp. Or if you want to compare her to other IFPs from the series like Harry Potter, also compare her to ITPs from the series like Mad-Eye Moody. Where does she exhibit Ti over Fi. I'm still open to INTP but not very. } These quotes (and to a lesser extent the ones I omitted) suggest social awareness and a preference for feeling over thinking. Contrary to popular belief, INTPs aren't just colder version of INFPs. @Klkatykat I agree. Most of her quotes have been just observations by the way. Fe would know how to manipulate and fi would be aware of an intense rage driving them to conquer. I'm a bit suspicious of the fact that Luna has 83 votes and Harry Potter only has 55. *little to do with being socially adept a prioriRead through the thread again and you indeed gave some other reasons; I apologize for misconstruing your argument. "I enjoyed the meetings too. Also she fits the stereotype of the hippy, quiet, dreamy, eccentric girl, so many INFPs will relate. Well here are some luna lovegood quotes:. INFPs are above all else sincere and individualist, both of which fit Luna perfectly. Not empty inside and neither is she. " [I Would actually argue intj appears the emptiest. INFP with some resemblence with INTP. i think she is a 9 instead of a 5 because far more sympathetic and tolerant with people than a 5 would be. But he can be a bit unkind, I noticed that last year. She is an INTP" [Actually alot of infps/enfps are like this (more enfps) they know and they're actually proud of it because they believe in expressing themselves. I keep seeing her being typed as intp and it's one of the funniest things. So you guys would say she is an idealist like an actual INFP like Harry Potter. I believe Luna is quite happy with who she is. In this site you can find out which of the 16 types this character 'Luna Lovegood' belongs to!. " See what I mean. ” “Oh, it’s been all right. They want to be aware of their emotions and deal with them personally. Whats agreed is her auxiliary Ne outlook which gives her a whimsical, dreamy outlook. The girl in this video is an INTP and you can clearly see that they resemble in personality. Also INFPs have Te, it's just inferior. Discover Array, and more, famous people, fictional characters and celebrities here!. And she doesn't care people call her Loony simply because she's happy with who she is. I believe Luna is quite happy with who she is. I believe both Ti and Fi are fiercely independent. She quite look like an INFP from the outside but the reason she do 'weird thing' is by mostly by curiosity (more an INTP hobbies). 3w4 hoping this is a joke INTP 9w1. Se and ne are VERY different. - She rarely gets offended and never takes things personally. They think that cause they think she is nice and cute. On your arguement that feeling types are more socially adept than their logical counterparts: This would be true in xxFJ types (Fe) but Fi is used mainly to address ones own feelings. :-(Hey guess what. The things that Luna believes are not impossible to exist in the magical world, they just have not been proven. Just because she claims intp doesn't mean she is one. I really don't know myself which type she could be. She is so undifferent to almost everything what happens, ever being so cold, doesn't seem to have a particular connection to anything, save for her interest in magical creatures, which is obviously a more intellectual interest than anything. -She is able to overlook negative aspects of her circumstance and rarely feel threatened but rather show detachment even in situations implying danger for her and her friends. People of a personality type generally act similar regardless of their gender. The entire strategic basis of the quote is emotion-based and very indicative of Fi. SHe isn't illogical, she uses a subjective yet impersonal logic; this is exactly why she looks eccentric/loony. Both INFPs and INTPs can be innocent.
. @Klkatykat Preach. Also compare how she clashes with Hermione's Te and how Harry clashes with Hermione's Te. No doubt about it. Also Obama is a Ti subtype ENTP. She's also superstitious and I don't really buy Ti-doms being like that. Some one please help me understand the INTP votes. Welcome to MBTIBase - PersonalityBase, here you can learn about Luna Lovegood MBTI type.. And anyway, it's not as though I'll never see Mum again, is it. She's one of the most infpish characters ever created. This whole ridiculous argument that she doesn't say analytical things is dumb. I believe both Ti and Fi are fiercely independent. My observations are only based on the movies - never read the books - so it might be a bit off because of that. com/guess-type/164727-luna-lovegood-intp-infp. Its possibility based. You're just as sane as I am. About a month ago I had mixed feelings about her but I'm more and more convinced she's an INTP. With only feeling you are a jellyfish, purely instinctual with only a need to feed, rest, and reproduce. Without thought you have no ability to sort your emotions. Typing daydreamy people as 9w1s is getting old. -She is also very detached from her emotions. She doesn't use feelings in a lot of situations, she uses logic instead of feelingsINFP 9w1. Not all INTP's are irritable, society-hating recluses, people. Why, she is such a NINE. Even if not directly tested, public voting can provide good accuracy regarding Luna Lovegood Myers-Briggs and personality type!. ” “Oh, it’s been all right. (And also, letter-by-letter, I still type her INFP as she's not at all analytical or logic-based but is very value-driven and emotional). html Not 100% convinced she is INTP (nor INFP either) but there are a lot of good points there. No; just as Te dominants are extremely logical in that they take the facts and systemize them into externally verifiable frameworks, so too are Ti dominants extremely logical in that they theorize and subject those theories and premises to factual analysis to make sure they are logically consistent. IXFPs can isolate themselves. The things she says are deep and emotional and weird not logical. "Hermione was initially frustrated with Luna's belief in all manner of things without logical grounds or proof. (They're so inside themselves emotionally and don't display an excess of of outer warmth) They can seem just as cold as intps in alot of cases. Same with isfps. She is anything but analytical. An esfp 2 is attracted to the idea of being an Enfj. It's also the one case when you can tell enneagram type from the tone of somebody's voice (from the movies at least). "She doesn't care" is actually a good way to sum her up, which sounds very Ti dom to me. It's quite clear that Fi > Fe. On the other hand, she shows little need for logic of any kind or analytical breaking down stuff or detailed examination of the world around her that is needed to qualify someone as a Ti user, let alone a Ti-dom. She is so INFP it hurts. The MBTI questionnaire sorts people into one of 16 different personality types.. As for example when she talks about her mother's death (it's something like "yes, my mother was blown up. To find out what your MBTI personality type is you need to complete the MBTI questionnaire and take part in a feedback session from a qualified MBTI practitioner.. She's Positive Outlook. Te from absolute fact and ti from self constructed logic. Alot of Intps don't appear very empty really, especially once they better develop Fe]. I think it's rather apparent that she's much closer to Harry than Moody. I too see her as INTP. metallic, ignore the generic female name accounts, they're all being owned under the same douchebag thanks for letting me know, do you know who's running them. ") She's totally disconnected from feelings that should be so profound and meaningful to her, but she still talks about them in a totally ""non-intense"" way, even though she's talking to Harry, who is one of the people who could best understand exactly how she feels (and it is from this similarity in her stories that Harry, as a Fi dom, sympathizes so strongly with Luna: because she, most than others, understands exactly what he is feeling). Jack is an intp. She just speculated on Voldemort's strategy using her own self as an example. Especially since 75% of the comments are pro-INFP. She was eventually getting more Thinking, not more Feeling. Harry will aggressively and directly clash while Luna will detach with her "I don't care" attitude. So it's not too bad. Most type 4s are attracted to the idea of being an infp on the mbti. I'm in art school and hate math/computer science so people would say I'm an INFP but I'm so essence/accuracy/objectivity matters more in my head. web counter9w1 INTP sx/sp. All her quotes have been observations or moderately warm. I'm even sad about it sometimes, because it was quite horrible, I suppose. Read my post again and Klkatykat's quotes and the other pro-INFP arguments. An infp could do this. I guess INTP > INFP. Harry understand is motivate by doing what is right luna is motivate by understanding thing around her (Ti). I'm an INTP and Luna is basically my spirit animal :p@Alkeris: Her father is an ENFP, and the curiosity is a result of Ne, which is equally prevalent in both INxP types. Whether or not the quote seems Fi to you, it can't possibly be argued as Ti or Fe. In the movies she always appear to be in her own fantasy world and is not a cold analyst. I always find fictional characters hard to type because most of them are multi faceted and can fit more than one type at a time and that seems to be the case with Luna. josephty1 (he also does the “you are loved” shit but that’s a given). Here you can explore of famous people and fictional characters.. Her interest in magical creatures is far more intellectual than anything. Intps aren't "loony". " xSTJ easily pointing out logical inconsistency of an INTP or a Five. They're fully based on helping everyone around them. Also why do you keep saying "intp girls". I don't even know why there is even a question about this. That would really be logic first, before beliefs, loyalty, feelings, anything. INTP's are not empty inside but out of the 16 types INTP's appear the emptiest. INTPs on the other hand seek independence of mind and seek universal truths and principles usually devoid of any values/beliefs to back them up, however unlike INFPs they don't seek to be different and are actually quite awkwardly different due to inferior Fe. Luna is an intelligent INFP, not an INTP. But I've still got Dad. L Lawliet (Death Note) (A perfect example of a logical eccentric). Whoops (I thought it said ". the funniest thing is that it's my another post that I spend too much time writing and thinking I'm right, but actually I read and watched Harry Potter quite long ago and I could be also wrong. As for typing fictional characters, yes you often have to go off of behavior, but no you don't have to by default. I don't really see Fi in her (I'm INFP), Ti makes more sense in my opinion. She is socially inept and blissfully unaware. "She says things that causes awkward moments. They're kinda like Luna but much more analytical and much less emotionally aware. Also INFPs are very aware of the social implications of their actions while INTP's are not at all socially attuned. She stopped two boys in our Transfiguration class calling me ‘Loony’ the other day-“ ". "She discovered and classified many species that had never been encountered before, but was never able to find the Crumple-Horned Snorkack; thus, she had to come to terms with the fact that there are some things that simply do not exist. The Myers Briggs is a system of explaining how they process and interact with the world. I said she's not at all analytical but is extremely emotionally sincere and warm inside. http://personalitycafe. Eric Foreman (That 70's Show). In the movie Mark is an INTP and that is completely out of character for an INTP. He was a great general and yet was a Fi dom. You haven't done that. You feel the inner peace from miles away. But also because her quirkiness is mostly fantastical not intellectual. It certainly wouldn't explain the opposite. Both INTPs and INFPs can have high self-esteem despite being considered eccentric by others. Fi and Fe are feeling functions, not feelings/emotions. I see her inferior Fe in her social ankward, difficulties in relating to the crowds, but still being able to recognize (to some degree) what others feel. An Fe-dom Luna would recognize and act on others' feelings, follow others' values, and take the world and aim to please it. -She has that typical repressed Fe that makes her quite unaware of people's rituals but at the same time secretly wishing to fit in. She came up with a possible explanation for voldemort's actions. That's extremely Fi. If anything her T function is inferior in that she seems to be unaware of the facts at times and never analyzes anything. I'll give you a different example that uses your exact logic: "I'm an INTJ. agree to degree. People only like to think of INTPs are being trollish tomboys or guys. Infps are notorious for sticking to their firmly held values. "someone made fun of her father or The Quibbler, of which he was editor, the airy, dreamy quality in her voice would vanish and be replaced by one of steel (almost as sharp as a double-edged sword), and she would immediately become very angry. She's not analytical or deductive at all. In the books she gets angry when people say her theories are wrong. I wrote my own whole opinion, I took only that specific quote because it fits perfectly with what I think and I couldn't say better even bc I don't speak English. Well here are some luna lovegood quotes: "I enjoyed the meetings too. Fe inferior is rather unlikely because "Fe seeks to identify what is moral by identifying what those around them value". Isabel Briggs Myers, a researcher and practitioner of Jung’s theory, proposed to see the judging-perceiving relationship as a fourth dichotomy influencing personality type.. As I said, it seems more like an intellectual interest, to discover new things, than passionate or sentimental, she is definitely not very tied to his own emotions and tends to leave them aside. 9w1 (positive 2-7-9 triad, denying problems) because she's too unpretentious and optimistic to be either 4w5 (reactive 4-6-8 triad, emotional with problems) or 5w4 (competence 1-3-5 triad, objective with problems). Actually when you really dissect the quote it seems totally fi-ne. She only wants to know about discovering new and different things in the magical world (not just magical creatures) that have not been proved, but which make sense to her and can exist independently of what has been proven or explained. Imagine your car getting totalled without insurance and talking to someone about it, it's just "a previous event". You haven't addressed any of the new pro-INFP arguments other than by throwing in a video and calling them ridiculous. Intuitives focus on a more abstract level of thinking; they are more interested in theories, patterns, and explanations. They are often more concerned with the future than the present and are often described as creative. A bit lonely without the DA. ) and personal sense of morality (unbreakable loyalty, peace, but most importantly classic and easily spotted Fi trait of being "herself" just because). I challenge you to analyze any of Luna's quotes logically. Yeah im not sure why so many people see her as INFP since she has no Fi. I know an isfp who everyone thinks is just pure and nice but when angered she's a fire breathing dragon. It was like having friends. "I still feel very sad about it sometimes. Her life is completely based around her Ti view of things and her Ne fantasies. I think Luna and Hermione are good examples of the logic of Ti-Ne vs Te-Si. She stopped two boys in our Transfiguration class calling me ‘Loony’ the other day" “There,” she said softly, “Now he could be sleeping. Intp 5s are like Einstein. The way she talks about feelings is also not very internalized. I've actually watched the video and that girl isn't intp. I'm xNFx but know of ExTPs that are more socially adept than I am. The thing is, though, even given the existence of magic in the Harry Potter world, Luna still isn't logical and yet is highly emotionally sincere. , and a mediator, and completly unaware of her anger. The things luna says indicate Fi. -She is all about how she understands the world, how she observes it, challenging established beliefs; not about her journey or who she is. She stopped two boys in our Transfiguration class calling me ‘Loony’ the other day-“. But F does mean that you are atleast socially aware. Harry has no Ne but compare him to INFPs like Frodo for example and the Fi dom similarities are pretty obvious nonetheless. INTPINFP 5w4 explains it the best I think. (Though not emotionally) xxTPs have Fe and know how to smooth out situations better than an xxFP would. Luna has very rarely succeeded to prove/explain that things she believes in are factual. Though we may have a feeling preference over thinking, that has nothing to do with our intelligence or intellectual capabilities. You are usually forced to type them by their behavior. And your analysis was so good. Fe is not about being peaceful individually like Nine, it's about living the lives of others which is so un-Luna. For Luna, it's all a matter of internal logic, whether or not it's proven. Does Luna do that. What is the best option for the MBTI type of Luna Lovegood? What about enneagram and other personality types?. INFP's are not capable of developing a strategy that would destroy a person. Sounds convincing right. Don't be fooled by her lack of outward warmth; she is not at all an analytical thinker but is indeed a sincere dreamer. Luna does it, Fe. Nothing she says is analytical or logical. Feeling and thinking are oxygen and carbon dioxide (they need eachother to work properly) Emotions are related to opinions. At last, I will talk about that scene when she relates and identify herself with Harry's story, an INFP would be so much more INTENSE than she went when finding someone that perfectly understand how she feelsI agree with this, she isn't really Fi actually. “Oh, it’s been all right. In favour of Ti :. Even for IxTPs, Fe seems superficially like a pain in the ass, but actually they're unconsciously driven to end up somewhat helping humanity with their Ti logic powers by improving universal, external standards of existing. And anyway, it's not as though I'll never see Mum again, is it. When she talks with Harry he is the one feeling uncomfortable because Fi can't be that detached about personal and fundamentally "human" themes like these. That quote is actually reminiscent of Fi as it puts her own self in Voldemort's shoes ("if I were You-Know-Who") and extrapolates off of that what Voldemort would want Harry to feel ("I'd want you to feel cut off from everyone else"). She's certainly not Fi dom. She doesn't have a trace of 1 in her. But OK, yes it was really wrong I recognize, sorry for thatShe probably is a 9w1 but anyone who is weird or a hermit is typed as a 4w5 or a 5. INTPS AREN'T LIKE THIS AT ALL. Neither of the trio seems to care much about being (or being seen as) "intellectual". " xSTJ easily pointing out logical inconsistency of an INTP or a Five. I asked if you thought April was istp or intp. She seems to be more worried about her inner peace and comfort than knowledge, she is very positive outlook and lighthearted, she also talks more like a 9 (head-in-the-clouds, daydreaming, random). Look at the quotes. When Te gets more mature later in life it's all about objective verification of previously held beliefs and getting more in touch with facts and pragmatic life. Luna is not like that. As for the "if you ever met an INTP girl you would know," that's anecdotal evidence and shouldn't really be used as part of your argument. Luna may or may not resemble INTPs (in my opinion, most of the time, not) but you have to prove she is an INTP using actual theory (prove Ti-Fe and/or T > F). Luna is a sensitive INTP, not an INFP. Eccentric, wise, considerate, and off in her own world. But Fi is more about accepting once's individuality and uniqueness, Fi combined with Ne gives INFP the idiocyncracy and dreamy outlook who are very comfortable with who they are. But Luna still feels a need to collaborate with the general welfare of society and her colleagues, such as when she joins Dumbledore's Army, and opposes Lord Voldemort because it is the right thing to do and the better thing for everybody. There is definitely a gap between her and Harry who is Fi dominant. Luna doesn't possess any specific Ti logic powers that could help the world, what she possess is Fi values powers which she reveals in the most delicate ways, except one time when. Luna is not analytical, deductive, or dispassionate; she's individualist, unique/eccentric, and gentle/kind. INFPs, like most introverts, are quiet and reserved. They prefer not to talk about themselves.. And if you're convinced by anecdotal evidence, which I gather you are, I know several female INFPs and INTPs. That's not a good argument. Some people call me ‘Loony’ Lovegood, actually. Luna is extremely different from that. If she's an INTP, she would one of the most nonsensical INTPs to ever live. I also see a pattern of votes for certain celebrities in the same order with same votes which rattles my suspicion. Harry understands her, Fi. Even in real life It's hard to catch Fi or Ti when somebody isn't a walking stereotype. Honestly I can totally see why people type her INTP. When 4s get unhealthy, they indulge in their emotions and want to feel everything even more intensely. Also I think Jack actually could be an INTP. If you enjoyed this entry, find out about the personality types of Harry Potter characters list.. “He says very funny things sometimes, doesn’t he. ”" with possibly some schizotypal disorder tendencies that are more associated with INTPs so it could be either an argument for her being INTP or, an INFP that because of this tendencies looks more like INTP ("Inappropriate or constricted affect (the individual appears cold and aloof); Behavior or appearance that is odd, eccentric or peculiar; Poor rapport with others and a tendency to withdraw socially; Odd beliefs or magical thinking, influencing behavior and inconsistent with subcultural norms; Unusual perceptual experiences including somatosensory (bodily) or other illusions, depersonalization or derealization; Vague, circumstantial, metaphorical, over-elaborate or stereotyped thinking, manifested by odd speech or in other ways, without gross incoherence"). But I didn't use that as part of my argument because that's anecdotal evidence. You can compare her to her father who is A real INFP. I'm not saying she doesn't use Ti at all, there are actually moments when her introverted reasoning is really on point, but overall not strong enough for a primary function. which fits really well with inferior Te narration. And I must say, though I generally stay away from Enneagram typing, wouldn't it make far more sense for an INFP 5 to act like Luna than for an INTP 5. Each type could be a dictator. And inner warmth. She is an ESFJ, ESFJs can be dreamers too, I know ESFJs who are just like her, therefore I conclusively determine she is an ESFJ, so now I'll spam ESFJ votes. She also seems to have no proper shame or fear, she's too distant and goes with the flow like all 9w1s do. So when harry want to do the right thing, it's Fi. It was like having friends. They may want to be introverted like their enneagram 4 self image. She is an INTPObvious infp. "You're being rather rude you know. The ultimate Type 9. " "Don't worry. Only typed as INFP because she's dreamy. Luna seems to be moved by curiosity (Ne) and while she may get hurt by what others do or say, it's never to do with her self-image. I think in movies she seems more INFP. And the INFPs much more closely resemble Luna in every way. Here's why Luna despite her subjective logic is not a Ti type: Ti is a function that is largely deductive and analytical in that it takes impersonal premises and principles and subjects them to logical analysis.
The new website will come out in ~10 days (hopefully before New Year), and meanwhile Im collecting money for the server,
so please excuse the excessive ads for a while. Also Happy Christmas and New Year, although I gotta be working. Thank you for supporting the development!
Category: Movie Characters
Series/Domain: Harry Potter