Stronger Ti: ESTP or INTJ Myers-Brigs type - MBTI, enneagram and personality type info
I never said anywhere that I was combining the two. I believe in typing with functions, not letters, not both, but I can still play devils advocate to myself and assume how someone would be typed in a system outside of my own personal belief. I think I’d meant to highlight the absurdity of trying to use function types to try and figure out how strong someone is in a function. Either way the answer here depends on the personality theory you are using What does ESTP mean. Which is why I'm arguing there being more INTJ votes. I think its more accurate, so I believe it to be more true. I would vote for INTJ being way more Ti than ESTP and both of them being about equal in Te. The intuitive bias is strong here. Intuitives focus on a more abstract level of thinking; they are more interested in theories, patterns, and explanations. They are often more concerned with the future than the present and are often described as creative. The total T function of INTJs should be stronger. Also to note, for Jung Ti would be one of the two “inferior functions” of his Se type. If you define something as having Ti then there is no way it wouldn’t have Ti regardless of how much it would relate to a Ti description. Se>Ti by functions. ESTPs Ti is problem resolving. So if I made a stronger Te : ESTP or INTJ people would vote ESTP. and the answer just depends on how you conceive MBTI. You wouldn’t really associate “Ti” with the ESTP archetype as much as you would with an INTJ. " - You seem to be mixing up me actually believing in a theory with me highlighting how something would be percieved within a theory seperate from my belief. ESTPs don't judge as much as INTJs in general so I don't think there needs to be any "consistency" in how one sees both situation. It’s beyond silly, really. "If Se > Ti is a requirement in defining “ESTP” then there’s nothing to discuss here. Here you can explore of famous people and fictional characters.. I did a little bit of data sorting on the data I've collected from my test and check it out: the average Ti score for 72 (Myers-Briggs) INTJs was 34. In this site you can find out which of the 16 types this character 'Stronger Ti: ESTP or INTJ' belongs to!. Now in the case of this question, I honestly think most people nowadays actually do a mashup of different systems to just come up with vague intuitive ideas of what functions and types are, like "INTJ is this" and "ESTP is this" and "Ti is this" and now let's associate those vague ideas and see which one relates the most to the others. "ESTP and Function Archetype ESTP are two different things" - thats literally what I just said, only to me personally I choose to believe more in the function archetype one, and am just seeing things from the other viewpoint to better inform the argument. But what really intrigued me was that Grant-Brownsword INTJs were also higher than Grant-Brownsword ESTPs on average even though the algorithm doesn't even take it into account for INTJs: 74 Grant-Brownsword INTJs scored 32. It sounds like I’m making a big strawman out of nothing but after months and months of discourse, I find it really hard to see anything further beyond that kind of justification from people who generally mesh bits and pieces together to make their MBTI archetypes. If you look at the definitions for the functions and try to type them in MBTI, you can compare what you get against whatever is postulated in these entries. " to mean that you define ESTP meaning both of these things together. " - Exactly, thats what I'm saying. (more likely the latter). The MBTI has evolved with different conceptions and those subdivisions are theories of their own, now you might say they should have different names but the thing is they're there and you can't actually get rid of them no matter how prescriptivist you might be (hence why fg hasn't slayed letter heretics yet). MBTI INTJs should relate to my test's Ti more than MBTI ESTPs. In the ESTP case of course Fi would be lower, but Ti in the Jung sense really isn’t even needed to be the first introverted function for that type or strong at all. I’d imagine it’s why the leading votes are inconsistent between these entries with regards to typing functions in MBTI These entries are either function typists being sarcastic, or letter typists trying to prove a point. And I believe functions more, so to me personally Se>Ti "The answer shouldn’t depend on what “personality theory” you’re using, honestly". "The only real issue is the kinship between different systems of definition and the common nomenclature that is derived from it. No, you’re totally right. The function definitions Myers provided in Gifts Differing describe Ti in a way which would be IN > J > T. I haven’t voted on any of these entries because the actual definitions people use to describe these functions vary way too much to be of any use, but assuming Ti is essentially I, T and a judging function (J) by definition, then it makes sense that an INTJ would relate to it more than an ESTP. For some it might well be Si This website and its users leave me speechless. We're in a website called "mbtibase" and you still have currently 11 people who vote INTJ for the following question "Which one between ESTP (Se-Ti-Fe-Ni) and INTJ (Ni-Te-Fi-Se) has the strongest Ti". Thinking – Feeling, represents how a person processes information. Thinking means that a person makes a decision mainly through logic.. Jung theorized that the dominant function acts alone in its preferred world: exterior for extraverts and interior for introverts.. I think the way people are voting on these entries is just with that—the notion of some collective archetype in mind and comparing it to the raw functions. Welcome to MBTIBase - PersonalityBase, here you can learn about Stronger Ti: ESTP or INTJ MBTI type.. Free in-depth and practical information on the 16 personality types, including careers and relationships.. Literally dumbfounded, I serisouly start to question the intellectual level of the people here. "What’s the point of asking a question like this if your definition of ESTP is “Se-Ti” and INTJ is “Ni-Te”. What is the best option for the MBTI type of Stronger Ti: ESTP or INTJ? What about enneagram and other personality types?. 82, and the average Ti score for 8 (Myers-Briggs) ESTPs was 31. 12 for Ti and 12 Grant-Brownsword ESTPs scored 30. " - I asked a question. Maybe if you wanted to vote for ISFJ you’d concentrate more on the 1-ish side of the housewife archetype and think of ENFP in a more 2-ish light, but those archetypes are rarer to come by in the typology community. Discover Array, and more, famous people, fictional characters and celebrities here!. I'm not really sure what this means either: "thats literally what I just said, only to me personally I choose to believe more in the function archetype one, and am just seeing things from the other viewpoint to better inform the argument. The reason I say the answer here depends on what system you use is because some letter people will argue that I and T in a type means they use Ti, or that using Ti means they are an IT type, which could be true in their framework if they see what in my belief is an ESTP, as an IxTx type. You are in the best place to test MBTI and learn what type Stronger Ti: ESTP or INTJ likely is!. I misinterpreted "Se>Ti by functions. The only “useful” thing you could pull out from such discourse would be whether people use four functions or eight functions. You guys are retarded. " Maybe you simply meant that you'd utilize one over the other but I find it super interesting you used the word "belief" to justify your partiality for typing using your system. Quiet, reflective, and idealistic. Interested in serving humanity. Well-developed value system, which they strive to live in accordance with.. Even if not directly tested, public voting can provide good accuracy regarding Stronger Ti: ESTP or INTJ Myers-Briggs and personality type!. They are smart in sensory things and best improvisation because they know how objects works and concerts. I get that my sample sizes are both small and wildly different between INTJs and ESTPs but I think it's still very telling. The only real issue is the kinship between different systems of definition and the common nomenclature that is derived from it. To highlight the dissent between the function typing community.
. I do think though that most of these voters are just going with whatever feels more right to them. If you enjoyed this entry, find out about the personality types of Stronger function characters list.. Extravert, sensing, thinking, percieving by letters. Extravert, sensing, thinking, percieving by letters. The MBTI has evolved with different conceptions and those subdivisions are theories of their own, now you might say they should have different names" - Indeed, which Is why I said the answer changes depending on the theory you believe, because an ESTP is different in each theory. This is kind of expected isn't it. "If I said INFP is Fi > Ne but defined Fi and Ne in a way that would be INTP in MBTI then I wouldn’t be able to come to an actual conclusion in a scenario like you’ve described. The ENFP vs ISFJ on Fi entry has ENFP winning now I think and it’s really nothing beyond the fact that people imagine ENFP to be the obstinate revolutionaries who are guided by their crazy ideas and the Fi behind them while ISFJ is the grand label for people-pleasing housewives who don’t have any opinions of their own. "but the thing is they're there and you can't actually get rid of them no matter how prescriptivist you might be" - Sad indeed or rather what an ESTP is defined as Oh, I see. This personality type is highly individualistic and Champions strive toward creating their own methods, looks, actions, habits, and ideas!. Exactly, so for those who come up with new useless theories on mbti everyday, please leave this website two months later and I still can’t figure out whether you were being serious or not @All_in its all good fam.
. A better way to put it is this: I'm giving an example of how the situation would be percieved under 2 seperate view points, while only believing one to be true.
Stronger Ti: ESTP or INTJ
The new website will come out in ~10 days (hopefully before New Year), and meanwhile Im collecting money for the server,
so please excuse the excessive ads for a while. Also Happy Christmas and New Year, although I gotta be working. Thank you for supporting the development!
Series/Domain: Stronger function